← The Latest

In Escrow in Orange and Told It's the FAIR Plan or Nothing?

When the state examines the FAIR Plan and finds a problem, a new law will make it fix the problem on a deadline. Here is what that means for a buyer.

Any port in a storm. In California home insurance, the port of last resort has a name, and you just heard it from your agent or broker: the FAIR Plan.

You are in escrow on a house in Orange. So is your old college roommate, on a house a couple of miles away. Same price range, same loan, same closing month, same nervous texts at midnight. The only difference is the answer each of you got about insurance. A regular insurance company will write her house. For yours, the only option on the table is the California FAIR Plan.

So what is the place you are being sent? The FAIR Plan is California's insurer of last resort, there for property regular companies will not take. It is not a state agency, whatever the name suggests. Insurance companies that sell property coverage here back it as a pool.

Your roommate gets a regular homeowners policy. You get something narrower. A basic FAIR Plan policy typically insures against fire, lightning, internal explosion and smoke. Typically it stops there, so theft, liability and water damage fall outside. That is why many owners buy a second policy from a regular company, often called a difference in conditions policy, to cover much of the rest. Ask your agent or broker to price that pairing before you close.

Now the question that keeps you up after the midnight texts. Who checks on the FAIR Plan? And what happens if it is doing something wrong?

State examiners at the Department of Insurance look the FAIR Plan over. A new law, AB 1680, the Make It FAIR Act, will add teeth to what comes after. Once the law takes effect, anything an exam finds will have to be fixed, on a timeline set by the Insurance Commissioner. And if a fix is missed? The FAIR Plan could be charged up to $20,000 for each failure.

The law will hand the Commissioner a couple of other tools too, such as the power to require the FAIR Plan to adjust the policy limits it offers and to require additional fair rental value coverage in its renters program. The Department says the law will strengthen the FAIR Plan's operations, claims handling and financial accountability.

So what does the difference between you and your roommate mean? This law is about the FAIR Plan, so your roommate should not count on it to touch her regular policy. For you, it means the last-resort insurer you are about to rely on will have to answer when examiners find a problem. Do not count on it to lower your price or decide who qualifies. Those questions stay with your agent or broker.

Before escrow closes, call your agent or broker and ask three things. Is the FAIR Plan really the only option for this address? What would the FAIR Plan policy leave out? And what would the second policy cost each year?

Then send your roommate a text. A calm one.

About Orange

Old Towne and the plaza

Orange, Orange County

Old Towne Orange is built around a circular plaza where Chapman Avenue meets Glassell Street. The square mile surrounding it holds more than a thousand homes and storefronts from the late 1800s and early 1900s, and the district has been on the National Register since 1997. Antique dealers fill many of the shops, and a fountain marks the center of the plaza.